Make the dough the night before and be sure it’s in a nice big bowl (so it doesn’t overflow!) and well covered (no one likes bug-buns!)
Yeast Mixture:
2 7g sachets of dried yeast
1 tsp white sugar
1 3/4 cups of warm milk (not hot!)
Mix above ingredients together and let sit for 5 to 10 minutes to get the yeast going and the milk frothy.
Dough Ingredients:
1/2 cup sugar (yes, more sugar!)
a pinch of salt
50g butter – softened (not melted though!)
4 cups good quality plain flour
1/2 cup sultanas (or you could add some currants as well!)
1 tbsp chopped mixed peel
1 egg
ground cinnamon, nutmeg and mixed spice – a good shake of each or about 1/4 tsp if you are shy
Make the dough:
Sift the salt and flour together. Sprinkle in the 1/2 cup of sugar. Now add the cinnamon, nutmeg and mixed spice. Rub in the butter next until well mixed. Plonk the egg in with the milky/yeasty mixture – and whisk with a fork to combine. Now pour the eggy/milky/yeasty mixture into the floury/buttery mix. Add the sultanas and peel. It might be quite sticky. Flour your hands and push on. Sticky is good. Sticky means they will end up moist and bubbly. Knead together with springy, spirit fingers until it’s all nicely combined and looks like a nice big lump of speckled dough.
First Rise (the night before!) :
Place into a greased bowl and sprinkle with some cinnamon and nutmeg. I brushed mine gently with some melted butter to keep it moist. You might like to do that if you can be bothered. Allow to rise covered with a clean cloth (until doubled in size). It will rise more quickly in a warm, draught free area.
Here is where you cover them and let it sit overnight. If you want the ‘do it in one day’ recipe look here!
Get up and shape your buns:
Good morning! I like your hair! Okay. Make a cup of coffee. Preheat your oven to 200C. Next, turn the dough out gently onto a floured surface. Don’t knead it! Just carefully cut it into rough square-ish pieces around 4cm square (or bigger if you like big buns!) Gently push them into a nice bun shape with your finger tips, as though you are a very gentle dough sculptor. You should get about 16 or so buns from this – enough for 2 trays – don’t worry if you get less (but don’t try for 20 or they’ll be TINY!) Grease your trays and pop the buns on – a little way apart – they will join together as they rise and bake.
Recovery Rise:
Now cover these nearly oven-ready buns with a couple of tea towels and let them rise again for half an hour or so in a warm spot. They may not double in size, but they will have time to recover and get ready to rise more in the oven.
While you are waiting you could pop over here and have a bit of a read?
Make the flour paste and get piping if you want traditional crosses:
Mix half a cup of plain flour with four or five tablespoons of water and pipe onto the uncooked buns in crosses (use a piping bag or a plastic bag with the corner snipped off a teensy bit)
Buns in the Oven:
Put your buns in the oven for 15 to 20 minutes. Put them as high up as you can in your oven, allowing room for the buns to rise upwards too. Keep an eye on them while the cook, they are a bit prone to burn on the bottoms. If they do, they’ll still be yummy, but obviously we want crisp bottoms, not burnt bottoms!
Make a pot of tea
While they are cooking make the sugary glaze to make your buns sticky!
Icing Crosses for Hot Cross Buns : instead of the traditional floury crosses :
Mix 1 cup of sifted icing sugar with 1 dessert spoon full of warm milk (or enough to make a piping consistency) – pipe onto your warm (not hot!) buns!
Variation for Fussy Kids:


these worked a treat pip… i did however burn the base of the first batch – even though they were possied on my top of toppest oven shelves. so i knocked back the heat to 180 in my old, non fan forced oven & yummy! ta ๐
These look great! I'm a bit late to make them for Easter morning but might try to start them this afternoon for baking tomorrow.
Thanks for sharing this Pip, had a go today and despite doing lots of stoopid things (haha) they still turned ut to be super tasty. a Fail proof recipe indeed! ๐
i haven't seen any hot cross bunnies here in santiago so i am going to make a batch tonight of your non religious version!
gracias por la receta.
I am still baking a batch now @ 11.30 pm and will make about 3 doz for family tomorrow, Whew!! But on the Crosses – I make them without till Good Fri, then the crosses go on for Good Friday. (I tell my kids its traditional, but really, I just can't be bothered!)
Yum! I was intending to do hot cross buns soon..but having not made them before I wasn't sure which recipe to go off. Will give these a go..especially happy about the overnight rise. The less kneading the better ๐
Yum – we have been making hot cross bun bread – so so yummy, my buns always turn out too much like rock cakes.
Just a thought about comments I meant to write yesterday – I hardly ever leave comments when I see Disqus – takes way too long compared to the blogger system (when you just click and it is done), I do make an exception for you Pip!
Yummo! These look delicious Pip!
Oh yes! I do totally get that, Kate! It does take a while, doesn't it?! I like the whole threaded comment thing, though… It's good to be able to reply directly underneath a comment… Darn you Disqus! Why can't you be FASTER?!
You should try this recipe for buns : they are not heavy… and maybe add a slosh of extra milk for good measure. Do not knead them after the first mix. They will do their thing and have a lovely crumb, I promise! xx
Thanks so much for the recipe, Pip – making my own buns was on my Easter to-do list!
Thanks so much for the recipe, Pip – making my own buns was on my Easter to-do list!
I've beeen making hot cross buns for over a week now. Buns with dried cranberries, buns with dried apple, and buns with choc chips. We have a bit of a sultana aversion in casa Williams so I'm always looking for alternatives.
You probably already know this, but traditionally, the hot crossed buns symbolise Christ's death on Good Friday. To eat them on Sunday when he's resurrected is a little like turning up late to the funeral, not realising it's been reversed.
But the buns look delicious!
I do know that! I hope I don't offend anyone by eating them on Sunday! Obviously I am not religious. Last year I got into trouble for not putting crosses on them! I guess buns can be fraught with difficulty. Maybe I will make Not Cross Buns (which I prefer!) again on Sunday, because that will keep everyone happy! Except the non-religious people who like crossed buns…!
Yummo!! I think i will make buns this afternoon with the kidlets, great school holiday activity. I wonder if I can find a Gluten free recipe? I think with this much flour it might not work just substituting GF plain flour? Anyway, thanks for the inspiration Pip!
Cheers
Vanessa
Eggs-cellent! I was thinking of baking some buns this Saturday. And now you have provided me with a recipe to follow.
You know, with all your different book projects, it won't be long before there is a Pip recipe book. ๐
Yummo! I have been making "not-cross" buns since the beginning of the year when Miss Six came home asking for hot cross buns in her lunch because her friends had them! In January! I complied on the bun part…but not the cross! Not until now anyway.
They look delicious. I wish I could eat one. I think I am too lazy to make them this year!
Did someone say lazy baker?! Then that's the recipe for me! Yay Pip – thanks!
xx
Thanks Pip! These look awesome.